Andrea’s Film Review – Jai Bhim

Jai Bhim ⭐⭐ Review by Andrea Carnevali

When a tribal man is arrested for a case of alleged theft, his wife turns to a human-rights lawyer to help bring justice. Available to watch on Amazon Prime.

Just a couple of days ago I stumbled across an article on the BBC which talked about an Indian film which out of nowhere had overtaken classics like The Godfather and The Shawshank Redemption and knocked them off the top spot of most rated film by the public on Imdb.

My curiosity as a film-nerd was just too strong and I had to set aside three hours (this is how long the film is) to watch it on Amazon Prime.

Jai Bhim, which literally translates “Long live Bhim” in Tamil, is based on a real story from the 1993 of Rajakannu, a man from the marginalised Irula cast in a very poor village, who is wrongly accused of robbery and is eventually arrested together with two other men. Over the next few days the three men are subjected to most brutal violence by the local police who are trying to get them to confess a crime they did not commit.

When one night they go missing from prison, Rajakannu’s pregnant wife seeks help of a lawyer and human-rights activist to help her fight the case against the police and get justice.

It is undoubtedly a very powerful story about a corrupt justice system, about the inequalities of the disadvantaged sections of Indian societies and about a remarkable real-life hero Chandru, the lawyer who apparently disposed 96000 cases in high court fighting for the poor, but clearly the makers of this film didn’t trust the power of the material itself, let alone their audience.

And so they feel the need to over-egg every single moment of the film in any possible way. Clearly they have never heard of the saying “less is more”.

Starting from the duration of the film itself, to its outdated aesthetics: Cinematographer S. R. Kathir is so concerned about making it look good that he forgot to give a reason for most of his meaningless angles – extreme close ups (like the absurd ones on typewriters as if it carried some unknown meaning), the many slomo shots, or the pompous and rather ridiculous staging of the action. Take for example the lawyer delivering cheesy lines of dialogue almost winking at the camera.

Not to mention the bombastic and ever-present soundtrack, which over-emphasised every single emotion happening in front of our eyes, just to drive the (obvious) point home: triumphal trumpets as the lawyer walks into frame (in slow-motion, of course), sad twinkly music as the wife cries. While he’s at it, a shot of a child screaming in distress is added, just in case you didn’t feel bad enough.

And what about the absurd and rather abrupt Bollywood-style songs, crowbarred in, which not only broke the mood but, in my view, diminished and undermined the impact and the power of the story itself?

Jai Bhim is a film devoid of subtleties: everything is spelt out, everything is shown, everything is shouted out loud, there’s not a whisper, not moment of silence, not even out of respect for the victims.

And last, but certainly not least, we need to talk about the violence. And believe me, there is a lot of that. We are not spared a single frame of beating, whipping and all sorts of other tortures. And as the blood pours out in great quantities (obviously with the extra added sound effects), we are insensitively forced to become voyeurs, heavily manipulated into a mix of rage and sadness and eventually we become almost immune to the horror, which I guess was really not the point of the film.

I have seen many Bollywood films before and loved many of them too, but certainly that style cannot be applied to every film, especially when the subject is so delicate (well, at least here they didn’t stop and dance all of a sudden. So I guess that’s a plus).

I honestly thought it was pretty dreadful and distasteful. The biggest mystery is how such film could have been highly rated by so many.

Andrea Carnevali is a Bafta winning film maker who lives in Chiswick.

Jai Bhim is available of Amazon Prime.

Read more stories on The Chiswick Calendar

See also: November Books – Reviews by Annakarin Klerfalk

See also: The Beauty Queen of Leenane at Lyric Hammersmith – review

See all the latest stories: Chiswick Calendar News & Features

Support The Chiswick Calendar

The Chiswick Calendar CIC is a community resource. Please support us by buying us the equivalent of a monthly cup of coffee (or more, if you insist). Click here to support us.

We publish a weekly newsletter and update the website with local news and information daily. We are editorially independent.

To subscribe to the weekly newsletter, go here.