Charles Dance on directing – Chiswick in Film Festival 2025

Emma Hayter, Charles Dance and Andrea Carnevali; photograph Can Mehmethanoglu

Andrea Carnevali in conversation with Charles Dance and Emma Hayter

Charles Dance was in Chiswick on Sunday (16 November), to take part in the fourth Chiswick In Film Festival.

The veteran actor, who has played more than 300 roles in television and film dramas and performed in more than 100 plays, (most recently in Strindberg’s Creditors at the Orange Tree Theatre in Richmond in September), was here for a screening of Ladies in Lavender (2004), the film with which he made his directorial debut.

Ladies in Lavender – Judi Dench and Daniel Brühl; image IMDb

“I think I know how to do this”

He came across the story when he was killing time on a set, he told the audience at Chiswick Cinema, waiting for the cinematographer to finish lighting the scene, which happened to be set in a library.

“It was a book of short stories, Faraway Stories by William Locke. I read them all, and I kept coming back to Ladies in Lavender. Images kept dropping down and I thought, ‘I think I know how to do this'”. So he set about writing a script.

The story is about two unmarried sisters, Janet and Ursula, who live together in a house overlooking a beach in Cornwall. One day they find a young man, washed up on the shore, unconscious. They take him in and nurse him back to health.

He speaks no English, but gradually they manage to communicate with him, they find out he is Polish, a musician who was on his way to America when he was swept overboard in a storm.

His presence alters the dynamic within the household, as Janet realises her sister is developing feelings for the handsome young man.

Maggie Smith and Judi Dench; image IMDb

Working with Judi Dench and Maggie Smith

In the book, the sisters are in their forties and the date is 1908. Charles changed the date to 1936, to give the international context a bit of an edge to it and to enable him to introduce a wireless, a useful prop in several of the scenes, and he had Judi Dench in mind for Ursula, who was then 70.

“I thought it would be great for Judi Dench, who was then in a David Hare play The Breath of Life with Maggie Smith”.

Remarkably he had never worked with either of them, but knew Judi slightly and took her his script.

Mimicking the two of them perfectly, Charles recalled Judi saying thoughtfully: “I think I’d like to do this” and asking who he had in mind to play her sister. When he tentatively suggested Maggie Smith, she immediately said: “Oh, Mags will do it.”

Maggie Smith asked: “Is Jude going to do it? Well, I’ll do it”.

They christened it ‘Lavender Bags’, and they were off.

Emma Hayter, Charles Dance and Andrea Carnevali; photograph Can Mehmethanoglu

The Chiswick In Film Festival is so-called because it celebrates Chiswick’s connections with the film industry, in this case Emma Hayter, the Executive Producer of the film.

Emma has also had a long career in the industry, working as a producer, executive producer, financier and filmmaker on a number of feature films and television series, including Lovejoy and Taggart for television, and the Bafta-winning film My Summer of Love.

She told the evening’s host Andrea Carnevali that with names like Charles Dance OBE, Dame Judi Dench and Dame Maggie Smith attached to the project, it was relatively easy to finance:

“It was an absolute slam dunk”.

Miriam Margolyes and Judi Dench; image IMDb

Miriam Margolyes was added to the cast as the housekeeper. They told the audience how Miriam, famed for her reputation as a phenomenal actress, but also notorious for her potty mouth and delight in shocking the unsuspecting, looked out of the cottage where they were filming one day to find the garden full of people in suits.

“Who are all those people?” she asked. When told they were the film’s investors she replied, “Well I’m a bit busy now, but I’ll be out later to give them all a blow job”.

Andrea asked Charles how he directed such eminent actors.

“Well I didn’t”, was the reply. When you have actors of that calibre you let them interpret the script to bring it alive.

“As an actor, if I can say something with a look, please let me do it, and get rid of the line”.

Charles Dance on what makes a good director; photograph Can Mehmethanoglu

What makes a good director?

Asked by a member of the audience what makes a good director, he said:

“One who creates an environment which makes the actors feel they can contribute something”.

The film relies on the chemistry of the two sisters. There are a lot of meaningful looks and silences that pass between them, which tell far more than any dialogue, and the filming, Andrea noted, is largely in a two-shot, showing the dynamic between them.

The Cornish scenery is stunning, but the story is about the women and the intensity of their feelings.

“I didn’t want the story to be dominated by the cinematography”, said Charles.

In the characters he plays as an actor, Charles Dance has cornered the market in ruthless villains and intimidating, powerful men, including Tywin Lannister in Game of Thrones, to Lord Mountbatten in The Crown, and Timothy Winthrop in Day of the Jackal.

Were there times when he needed to assert himself and employ some of that familiar imperiousness?

“One day Judi was being uncommonly sentimental, and I said: ‘Jude, it’s a bit Celia Johnsonish’.

“How dare you?” she said, “And take your hand off my knee”.

There was also a line about which Maggie Smith said: “This is a big of a pig’s ear, Charlie”.

To which he replied “Yes, it is”, so she simplified it for him into something she would say more naturally.

Audience for the Q&A on Sunday; photograph Can Mehmethanoglu

The power of the grey pound

Despite the stellar cast and director, the film was not easy to get into cinemas, he said, because it was aimed at an older demographic, but it stayed on in cinemas far longer than some of the megabuck blockbusters released at the same time.

Now, 20 years on, cinemas have woken up to the power of the grey pound, he said:

“I was doing Strindberg at Richmond with Geraldine James. We were both in Jewel in the Crown“, (the 1984 TV series about the British Raj which gave Charles his big break).

“The audience reflected that. They’d come to see how Geraldine and I were holding up. Some nights it was looking out at The Thursday Murder Club“.

Charles will be back as we know him, steely-eyed and intimidating, as the villain in the second series of Day of the Jackal, with Eddie Redmayne and Lashana Lynch, which they are filming at the moment.

READ ALSO: Nigel Lindsay on making a comedy about Islamic terrorism – Chiswick in Film Festival 2025

Emma Hayter, Andrea Carnevali, Bridget Osborne and Charles Dance; photograph Can Mehmethanoglu

Read more stories on The Chiswick Calendar