Ealing Council blasted by opposition for rewarding ‘distinctly average’ provider with a multi-million pound contract extension
Greener Ealing operative inspects uprooted tree as part of a wide-ranging remit
At a recent Overview and Scrutiny Committee meeting, the opposition challenged Ealing Labour as to why Greener Ealing’s contract was renewed for five years
In the Southfield ward of Chiswick and throughout the borough of Ealing, residential roads are serviced by Greener Ealing (GEL) who provide flytipping clearance, street cleaning, recycling and rubbish collection as well as parks maintenance and parking enforcement.
The Labour council’s Cabinet decided on 7 October to extend this contract for five years (bringing the whole contractual term to 15 years), saying that because of the Local Authority Trading Company (LATCO) status of their council-owned waste collection company they are able to provide better value for money to Ealing residents and don’t need to put the waste services out for competitive tender.
Untidy streets upset residents
Inconsistencies in the service
But opposition councillors say there is anecdotal evidence from their case work that suggests residents are unhappy, complaining of dirty streets and flytipping.
LAGERCan, a volunteer group who do litter-picking, said “LAGERCan’s experience of GEL has ranged from brilliant to not great”.
There are concerns, too, around the poorer performance of the cleaning of street leaves over the last two years.
As a result, the opposition requested what is known as a ‘call-in’ challenging the extension of GEL’s contract and asking for a cross-party committee to discuss whether the cabinet should or should not reconsider its decision.
Unmown grass and flytipping are issues that concern residents
Further scrutiny required
At the subsequent Overview and Scrutiny Committee (OSC), Lib Dem Councillor Jonathan Oxley, Shadow Spokesperson for Finance put the opposition’s arguments to the panel, saying:
“This is not an ideological debate… we don’t object in principle to services being delivered by a local authority-owned company like GEL, provided it performs well and it offers value for money. Unfortunately, GEL’s performance is distinctly average, and that is simply not good enough for our borough.”
“It is highly unusual for an extension of this size, circa £350 million (whole-life value), to be non-competitive and this alone warrants further scrutiny.”
Councillor Dominic Moffitt, the Cabinet Member for Climate Action, refuted assertions made by the opposition. He told the committee that it was not an “uncompetitive process”, claiming a full tendering process would have cost £120,000 not £12,000.
Leaves are always a problem and the opposition say GEL’s street cleaners have been significantly reduced
No procurement process?
He explained that the council does not need to go through any kind of procurement process because of the set-up where GEL is wholly owned by Ealing Council.
“Ealing Council manages GEL and it is scrutinised by a management board with representatives from the council and that is then managed by a shareholder committee which is the political leadership of Ealing Council. At every level, we have the ability to control the future of GEL and that ensures it is completely responsive to the needs of the borough.”
Cllr Moffitt pointed to two areas where GEL had surpassed the former (private) contractor including improved performance and increased social value. As a result of hiring GEL there has been a 17 per cent reduction in emissions across the borough and many more women employed in an industry dominated by men – all of them paid the London living wage.
He also outlined how complaints have reduced from 3,000 a year to fewer than 200 in 2023.
“This is a record of success,” he concluded.
More than one metric needed
But the opposition believes that use of complaints as a measure of success is not appropriate as many residents say they are fed up with reporting issues as most times they do not get resolution.
Cllr Oxley pointed to other metrics and cited ongoing failures regarding vulnerable residents.
“The target for missed assisted collections for disabled and elderly residents is zero, yet GEL has persistently missed that target since 2020, disproportionately impacting vulnerable residents. None of us should be content with this.”
Defending GEL’s record, Cllr Moffitt said:
“In the last couple of years, there have been between eight and ten missed assisted collections. There are 3,000 in the borough every fortnight – that’s 0.3 per cent of those collections that are being missed.
“While the target is zero because we absolutely want to make sure we get all of those done, I don’t think we should think that this represents some enormous egregious failure of service delivery to some of our most vulnerable residents, who are actually well looked after by GEL across the borough.”
Greener Ealing operates a large fleet of vehicles from mowers to recycling lorries
Future capital expenditure
Cllr Oxley, who continued to maintain that GEL’s performance is “distinctly average”, argued that a competitive tender would provide a better test of value for money and that the Shadow Bid and Value Assessment, commissioned by the council to demonstrate GEL’s competitiveness, does not adequately account for future investment costs.
This is thought to be significant given that the provider’s large fleet of rubbish and recycling vehicles are at the end of their life and need to be transitioned to electric vehicles.
Cllr Oxley concluded that the financial assessment underpinning GEL’s extension is “backward looking” and “flawed”.
“The administration’s inability to provide any projection of the cost of vehicle renewal demonstrates a reckless disregard for financial prudence.”
The Liberal Democrats also questioned the transparency of the cabinet’s decision since residents can not examine the Shadow Bid, which is confidential, but Cllr Moffitt pushed back saying that opposition councillors had been able to read it and given two separate opportunities to question the content.
Ealing has one of the highest recycling rates in London, but like anywhere has poorly recycled mess to clear
A properly executed process?
In defence of the extension, Cllr Moffitt said that the opposition’s challenge was “highly ideological” as the meeting was ultimately not about GEL’s record – which he said compared favourably with other London boroughs – but whether the process through which the council took their decision was properly executed.
“GEL’s performance is anything but average,” he said, citing a cross-party OSC report which showed Ealing had managed to keep costs down while maintaining one of the highest recycling rates in the city.
The data, published last February, found Ealing had the third-lowest cost per head for waste disposal, recycling and trade waste combined; the eleventh-lowest cost of street cleansing per head; and the lowest cost for parks and open-space maintenance across London.
In summing up, the Cabinet Member for Climate Action said he was confident the administration had made “an open, honest and transparent” decision focused on delivering value for money for the residents whilst Cllr Oxley for the opposition said “It is reckless and we’re making a blind decision. What exactly are the capital expenditure requirements that we face?”
After hearing all arguments, the committee – which has a Labour majority – voted to reject the opposition’s challenge, ultimately upholding the original cabinet decision.

Support The Chiswick Calendar
