Heirs & Grievances: how Britons fought to the death for their inheritance

A depiction of a medieval trial by combat

In the first of a new weekly series, James Thellusson traces a thousand years of blood feuds, trial by combat and sieges fought over the family fortune

Battles over inheritances are rising, as Baby Boomers pass on over £5.5tn to their heirs. But these feuds are nothing new. Throughout history, people have stopped at nothing to get their hands on the family fortune, including murder. Over the next six weeks, ‘Heirs & Grievances’ looks at some of the most deceitful and violent attempts to claim the family silver since 1066. How far would you go?

Leon Humphreys was appalled. The Driver and Vehicle Licensing Authority (DVLA) had fined him £25 for failing to tell them his Suzuki motorcycle was off the road. Rather than pay the fine, Mr Humphreys challenged the DVLA to trial by combat.

The sixty-year-old mechanic said, ‘I am willing to fight a champion put up by the DVLA with samurai swords, Gurkha knives or heavy hammers…but they must remember it is a fight to the death.’

Sadly for Mr Humphreys, trial by combat had been removed from the statutes in 1819, almost two hundred years before he issued his challenge in 2002. The Suffolk magistrates refused to fight and instead fined him £300 for wasting their time. His attempt to cock a snook at the legal system backfired.

If Mr Humphreys had been a Norman living between 1066 and the 15th century, however, his request for trial by combat would have been taken seriously. Under Norman law, men had to be ready to defend their inheritances ‘by oath and by battle’ (parati probare per sacramentum et per pugnam), and litigants could request a writ of right to trial by combat, often over land disputed in a will.

Now, trial by combat seems illogical and unjust. How can ‘might’ be ‘right’? At the time, most people were illiterate, most wills were oral, and wills and testaments were often forged by unscrupulous scribes and monks. In the absence of clear written evidence or testimony, the Normans regarded trial by combat as an honourable and legitimate way to resolve a dispute. After all, God could be relied on to protect the innocent and punish the wicked.

The first trial by combat was fought in 1077 between the Bishop of Worcester and Abbot Walter of Evesham, or rather by two ‘champions’ chosen to represent them. The dispute was over the jurisdiction of land. The battle was stopped by the King. Others were not. A dispute over the manor of Lesnes in Kent, for example, was settled in favour of Rose of Dover by a duel in front of the King’s justices at Chelmsford in Essex in 1227.

Trial by combat was a judicially regulated spectacle, not a spontaneous punch up in the pub car park. Dates for the fight were set by the courts, the contests advertised, and the contestants or their champions entered a specially constructed arena, a level square sixty feet on each side, to the sound of fifes and trumpets. Judges sat on the east side on raised benches in their robes, and the spectacle was managed by heralds and a Sarjeant at Arms.

Combats were also entertainments. Tothill Fields, in Westminster, was the Wembley Stadium of its time (‘no mead was so fit / For Courtly joust or tourney brave’). Combats there could attract crowds of 4,000. If the fight was cancelled, the champions, armour-plated celebrity gladiators, would sometimes offer to put on a fight to ensure the crowds did not go home feeling cheated, though the fight would not go to the death.

Trials by combat were one-on-one battles, like a knightly joust. But sometimes inheritance disputes would fester over generations, blood feuds which would burst into flames, sucking in whole counties, friends, families and their servants and wider retinues.

In 1570, Allan Stewart was kidnapped in the Woods of Crossraguel, Scotland, by 16 men working for Gilbert Kennedy, the Earl of Cassilis. The kidnappers took Stewart to ‘the black vault of Dunure castle‘, stripped him and tied him in front of a spit and roasted him until he signed away his right to the lands. Stewart eventually recovered his land.

In England, the Wars of the Roses (1455-1487) created a period when the law was weak, and several nobles took the opportunity to violently settle disputes. Among them was the Duke of Norfolk, who claimed to have bought Caister Castle, which was built by a knight called Sir John Fastolf, not to be confused with Shakespeare’s Falstaff.

Caister Castle in Norfolk, built by Sir John Fastolf and besieged by the Duke of Norfolk in the 1460s

The Duke of Norfolk’s claim was disputed. But rather than settle in the courts, the Duke laid siege to the castle with a force of 3,000 armed men, including archers and culverins, a type of long-barrelled cannon. After three weeks, the small garrison surrendered, as recounted in John Goodall’s The Castle (Yale University Press).

One of the most notorious of these feuds occurred at Nibley Green in the Cotswolds in 1470. North Nibley is a village on the edge of the Cotswolds, famous for its monument to William Tyndale, a Protestant executed for translating the Bible into English, and for the battle of Nibley Green, the last pitched battle between private armies on English soil.

The site of the battle of Nibley Green in Gloucestershire

Nibley Green was an armed solution to a long-running inheritance dispute between Viscount Lisle and Lord William Berkeley over farmland and tenements in Gloucestershire. Unable to settle their differences in court, Berkeley issued a challenge to Lisle on 19 March: ‘Fail not to be at Nibley Green at eight or nine of the clock and I will not fail to answer thee…’

Lisle arrived at Nibley Green with 300 armed men near the stream of Swynebourne. Berkeley brought a larger army of 1,000 men. Before Lisle could put on his bevor, the armour protecting the lower face, he was shot in the face by two arrows. With their leader down, Lisle’s men panicked and Berkeley’s men ran amok. 150 died in the battle, though the dispute was not settled until 1609, in a court of law.

After the Wars of the Roses, pitched battles declined. Duels between individuals over their right to succeed to a title or control the family silver continued on into the 19th century, as the British upper classes clung onto the right to duel to protect their honour and their estates.

Next week: Duelling Dukes

James Thellusson is a writer  living in Chiswick. He is the author of ‘School’s Out: Truants, Troublemakers and Teachers’ Pets’, and has written for The Oldie, The Idler and Management Today. He won the Sandstone Press Prize for Short Fiction. He is writing ‘Heirs & Grievances’, a history of famous feuds and inheritance disputes, from which this series is drawn. His agent is Andrew Lownie. James previously wrote ‘Man in the Middle’ for the Calendar and is published in the recent anthology of cricket poems ‘Catching the Light’.