Mirtala – Restaurant review
A confident new neighbourhood Mexican where quality reigns supreme
Guest review by Claudia Hearne
Independent restaurants are sadly becoming an increasingly rare commodity in London, so every opening feels like a small act of optimism.
Mirtala, occupying the former Sam’s Kitchen site on Turnham Green Terrace in Chiswick, is exactly the sort of business locals should want populating their high street.
Behind it are husband-and-wife team Benaisha, who works in Parliament, and Rishad, whose background is in tech. Neither of them have worked in hospitality before and somehow, alongside launching a restaurant, they’re also raising a 14-month-old baby at home.
It’s an impressive undertaking, and thankfully the food suggests the inevitable sleepless nights and laborious days have been worthwhile.The restaurant describes itself as North Mexican inspired, but rather than relying on familiar Tex-Mex clichés, the menu leans into carefully executed dishes with quality British produce and considered Mexican influences.
The meal began with Summer Guacamole, served alongside thick, golden corn tostadas. The guacamole was fresh, chunky and packed with flavour, while the tostadas struck that perfect balance of crispness with just enough richness from the frying to make them deeply satisfying.
Served at the same time was the Aguachile de Callo – hand-dived Orkney scallop cured and diced into a beautifully fresh ceviche. The quality of the scallop shone through, although for my English palate the chiltepin chilli tipped slightly too far towards heat, slightly dominating some of the delicate sweetness of the shellfish.
The Pollo con Masa was moist chicken encased in a substantial corn-based batter, fried to an even golden brown, accompanied by a tangy habanero cream and house-made pickles that brought welcome acidity.
We were given a heat warning for the habanero cream but the chiltepin chilli of the previous course had thankfully already won the Scovile Scale medal for the evening.
While I couldn’t immediately see the Mexican link, as soon as I bit into the crispy coating, the corn flavour transported me immediately to the land of mezcal and mole.As the plates were cleared, we were asked to keep our knife and fork for the next course.
Not a major issue, but it felt slightly at odds with the tone set by the crisp white tablecloths.The biggest surprise arrived with the Mirtala Barbacoa Taco.
Seeing “British Wagyu” alongside “barbacoa”, I had expected slow-cooked shredded beef with perhaps a token amount of Wagyu to justify the menu description.
Instead, beautifully seared pink slices of beef arrived, nestled inside an impossibly soft flour tortilla with a vibrant relish and more of those excellent pickles.
It was buttery soft, beautifully cooked and probably my favourite course of the evening. If it wasn’t already clear then this clinched it – Mirtala are serious about their ingredients.Dessert was equally well judged.
Sweet roasted pineapple came with lime crema and cinnamon ice cream, creating a classic balance of sweetness, richness and acidity that left the meal on a bright, refreshing note rather than an overly indulgent one.To drink, we started with a spicy Mezcalita, the smoky cousin of the classic Margarita.
During the meal, a smiley Benaisha stopped by our table with two fascinating Mexican corn spirits: Abasolo, an ancestral corn whisky, and Nixta, a sweet corn liqueur.
A memorable touch that reflected the couple’s obvious enthusiasm for introducing diners to lesser-known aspects of Mexican food and drink.
The wine list had a surprisingly limited South American selection, with just one sparkling and one red from Argentina. Instead, we chose a carafe of Doppio Passo Primitivo for £21, which proved to be outstanding value – rich, smooth and an excellent match for the food.
Service throughout was warm and genuinely welcoming. Benaisha and Rishad clearly care about what they’re building here, and that enthusiasm filters through the entire experience.
Independent restaurants like this matter. The recent loss of local favourites including La Vacherin, Sam’s Kitchen and Silver Birch has left a gap in the W4 dining scene.
Mirtala feels like the start of a new chapter: the sort of ambitious independent that both gives locals something to be proud of and gives Londoners a reason to make the journey west. Chiswick is all the richer for having it. Olé!
Mirtala are a Chiswick Calendar club card business, you can see their page here.

Support The Chiswick Calendar
