Opponents’ arguments ignored by Ealing Council as Walpole Park theatre motion is lost
Save Walpole Park protesters gather outside Ealing Town Hall
After councillors at a full council meeting were forced to debate an unpopular plan for a 1,200-seat temporary Troubadour theatre in Walpole Park, the vote went in the Labour-run council’s favour to press ahead with their controversial project.
In spite of powerful speeches given by Liberal Democrat, Conservative and Green councillors showing that an industrial-scale commercial venue at the centre of a Grade II Listed park was ill-judged and should be dropped, Labour continued to insist that the commercial opportunity should be explored as it would invigorate the local economy.
The venue for the proposed theatre would be the height of five double-decker buses say opponents
Testing demand for a theatre
On 9 September, the council’s cabinet had previously agreed in principle to explore bringing the temporary theatre to Walpole Park for over three years. The temporary structure would be located in the middle of the park.
Leader of the Council Peter Mason had then said the Troubadour theatre would “move the West End west”. At the full council meeting on Tuesday (13 October), he also claimed that it was a way to test whether Ealing could attract enough audiences to support a permanent venue.
“If it fails, it goes. If it succeeds, it goes. If we don’t achieve terms with the theatre provider, it won’t happen. If it fails planning, it will not happen.”
Not thought through?
Throughout the debate Labour’s leadership refused to acknowledge the loss of green space, the impact on the local community and possible damage to much-loved existing summer festivals that will be moved elsewhere. According to opponents of the theatre, financial risks were also not adequately addressed.
Liberal Democrat councillors Connie Hersch and Ksenia Maximova
Over 8,000 residents signed petitions
The motion to drop the plan for a large-scale theatre was led by Liberal Democrat Councillor Connie Hersch, the party’s culture, sports and communities spokesperson and seconded by Walpole Lib Dem Councillor Ksenia Maximova.
Outside Perceval House, protesters demonstrated and a number of them attended the meeting, while others watched online. In total over 8,000 signatories signed three separate petitions and Save Walpole Park’s petition had attracted 5,250 signatures by 4 October, exceeding the 3,671 required to seek a full council debate.
Recently the threshold levels of a petition to trigger a debate was substantially raised by Ealing Labour to reduce debate on resident matters. Despite the target being hit, it was not clear, until the very last minute, that opponents would get their full debate.
Risk-benefit analysis needed
Save Walpole Park campaigner Marc Goodchild, who lives in the Walpole ward, wants to see a comprehensive risk-benefit analysis carried out because if you examine Troubadour’s operating model it has always used brownfield sites and operated with a ‘meanwhile’ lease.
He finds it strange that the council defend their choice by maintaining “the only venue is the park” and accepting Troubadour’s own review of alternative locations. Marc and his fellow campaigners are also alarmed that financial information has been redacted from council documents, believing that there should be more transparency.
He said:
“In the cabinet meeting documents, they kept floorplans – as seen in Appendices 1 and 2 – but removed Appendix 3 because of financial sensitivities. When you look at the page numbers it seems fifty missing pages have been taken out of the public domain. If it’s the basis of their decision, then residents ought to know.
“We believe there are at least ten Freedom of Information requests that have been submitted to the council and three of these have passed the date by which they should have had a reply.”
Unrealistic ambition?
Fellow campaigner, Joanne Croxford, who lives near the park, has worked in the music industry for 20 years, touring with bands and often spends summers at festivals all around the world.
“If this proposal goes ahead, it’ll be like living in Glastonbury for three years,” she said. “At the full council meeting, it was clear they are so focused on money-making they’re not thinking of the physical ramifications of a large-scale enterprise – generators, plumbing systems, arctic trucks, tracking that’ll kill the grass, anti-social behaviour. It’s going to be really loud and unmanageable.”
“With my knowledge of the entertainment business, I would seriously question the level of income [Troubadour] will get because people are not buying theatre tickets in this financial climate. It’s a daydream that they are going to fill so many seats.”
Theatre seats are tricky to sell
Ealing Conservative leader, councillor Julian Gallant, who also has experience in the theatre industry, warned the meeting that even West End productions fail. He also doubted that Troubadour could fill 1,200 seats night after night. He wanted to know where the demand for the theatre had come from given that over 8,000 residents have signed petitions.
Currently the park hosts a number of festivals that are well attended and reliable income generators, but these could be jeopardised to accommodate a risky venture that Cllr Gallant referred to as “a punt”.
Existing summer festivals enjoy recognition for their excellence
Much loved festivals to be relocated
“Wherever I go – even as far as the USA – people have told me that we’ve got a fabulous jazz festival,” said Joanne Croxford. “They’ve heard of Ealing!
“If the jazz event is forced to move it won’t have the same following elsewhere. To remake the festival in another space will ruin the reputation they have built up every year.”
As well as local park-based events, Ealing is home to the Questor’s Theatre in Mattock Lane, just near the park.
Liberal Democrat Councillor Connie Hersch, said:
“Liberal Democrats think that replacing the longstanding Ealing Summer Festivals programme with a much more risky and financially unstable model of a large theatre just over the road from the largest community theatre in Europe is madness!
“It is not wanted by residents, takes up a third of the park green space and seems a risky venture given that Troubadour in Enfield was recently terminated with a large financial penalty for the Council.”
Walpole Park is in a conservation area
The fight goes on
Opposing councillors and the residents from Save Walpole Park have vowed to fight on. Ealing Lib Dems will keep their petition open online (now up to 3,500 signatories) and they will be sharing when the Labour council’s consultation is due to go live so that interested parties can participate.
Save Walpole Park has just set up a campaign website and will be posting how residents can help. On 24 October, to celebrate the 125th birthday of Walpole Park, they will be highlighting the park’s ecological importance with a tree walk led by an arboreal specialist.
Read more: Save Walpole Park
“There’s a lot of local talent – with expertise in relevant areas – and those people are mobilising,” said Marc Goodchild. “We’ll be bringing that experience to the public consultation. Residents are not going away quietly.”

Support The Chiswick Calendar
