Ruth Cadbury initiates debate in Parliament about crime in west London

Image above: Ruth Cadbury MP, leading the Adjournment debate on crime in west London, Monday 3 July

“We are scared to walk outside alone, we are scared to wear a watch, we are scared for the safety of our children”

Ruth Cadbury, MP for Brentford & Isleworth, raised the issues affecting crime in west London in Parliament on Monday 3 July.

There is a half-hour adjournment debate at the end of each day’s sitting, which back benchers can apply for, to give them the opportunity of raising an issue they particularly care about and receive a response from the relevant Minister. The subjects are chosen by ballot.

Ruth won the ballot to raise the subject of crime and antisocial behaviour in west London. Fellow Labour members from neighbouring London constituencies, Andy Slaughter from Hammersmith and Seema Malhotra from Feltham and Heston, supported her with comments about their constituencies, and Home Office Minister Chris Philp replied on behalf of the Government.

Ruth talked about the crime survey she had recently carried out amongst constituents, the results of which were more shocking, more worrying than the previous one she had carried out in 2019, she said.

“Debates about crime are not abstract. It is not a line on a bar chart, but so much more. It is often a life shattered, confidence taken away and a hole left behind.”

She told the House what one constituent had said to her:

“We are scared to walk outside alone, we are scared to wear a watch, we are scared for the safety of our children.”

“Crime has an acidic and poisonous impact on communities” Ruth continued, “whether that is cars being violently stolen outside of houses, homes being broken into, schoolchildren being mugged at knifepoint or young people afraid of getting involved and being sucked into gang activity.

“Children are afraid of being the victims of crime. They are also afraid of the gangs. Too many parents and young children are being targeted and, once sucked in, if they do not have the money to pay the gangs back, it is difficult to get out.

Image above: Ruth Cadbury MP, leading the Adjournment debate on crime in west London, Monday 3 July

Lack of faith in the police

The MP for Brentford and Isleworth spoke of her constituents’ lack of faith in the police and the effects of crime.

“The fear that crime puts into victims lasts so much longer than the time taken to experience and report the crime itself.

“Something wider has also emerged in recent years: a sense of broken Britain.

Phone theft, she said was “virtually legal” because of the lack of police action to do anything about it. Certain types of crime were just allowed to happen, she said because they were not policed. Anti-social behaviour seemed to be allowed to happen in plain sight.

“There is a sense that this is a country where certain forms of crime simply happen without any consequence.”

She had over 300 responses to her crime survey, she told the House, and 35% of those who had responded had been victims of crime in the last 12 months – mostly theft of vehicles and catalytic converters, as the A4 / M4 roads running through the constituency made for an easy getaway.

The top three areas people had told her they were concerned about were burglaries, violence and sexual crime and drug-related crime.

Antisocial behaviour feeds into the sense of hopelessness and powerlessness

Antisocial behaviour was also frequently bought up by constituents, she said, “although the phrase rather obscures just what that crime is.

“Whether it is constant fly-tipping on estates, long-running harassment campaigns against neighbours or illegally modified bikes speeding through parks, it feeds into the sense of hopelessness and powerlessness and the sense that our justice system is simply not working as it should.”

Image above: Andy Slaughter, Ruth Cadbury and Seema Malhotra

Andy Slaughter – “What’s missing is that neighbourhood policing we used to have”

Andy Slaughter, MP for Hammersmith, said in his constituency antisocial crime had increased since the Covid pandemic.

“I am grateful to my hon. Friend for securing the debate. She is describing something familiar to all of us in west London. In the post-covid period, there has been a rapid increase in antisocial behaviour, vehicle crime and drug-related crime.

“I have an active local authority that has more CCTV cameras per head of population than any other in the country and which has employed 70 law enforcement officers of its own. What is missing is the neighbourhood policing that we used to have that reassured local communities and gathered intelligence. That really did make a contribution to both reassurance and keeping crime down, and that is what we need back.”

Ruth Cadbury agreed:

“In the noughties we had five community police for each ward, but they have been cut to less than half that.”

Metropolitan Police Commissioner Mark Rowley had met London MPs following the Casey report and he realised the enormous amount of work there was to be done to convince the public the police were interested in their fears and concerns, she said, but currently the response people had when they reported crimes was usually either no response at all or just being given a crime reference, she said.

“A crime reference number is not justice served.”

Government decision to cut 20,000 police officers very damaging

She raised the issue of police numbers, saying the Conservative Government’s decision to cut 20,000 experienced officers (2,000 in London, 80 in Hounslow) had been very damaging.

She and her Labour colleagues had warned about this when she was still a councillor and deputy leader of Hounslow Council. The Government had realised it had been a mistake, she said, but now the experienced officers had gone out the door and it was difficult to recruit new officers.

She talked about cuts to local councils in services such as youth services which provided support, and how that had also had a detrimental impact, leaving individuals such as Astrid Edwards, who set up Action Isleworth Mothers to provide support for parents whose children were being seduced into gangs.

“Meanwhile, the Government have been bystanders on the issue of crime and the causes of crime. On their watch, the number of arrests has halved, prosecutions have almost halved and the number of crimes solved has halved.”

Ending on a positive note, she spoke also about getting CCTV installed on a housing estate and persuading the police to add extra foot patrols so people felt safe.

“We have seen some signs of improvement locally in recent months. We have a new dedicated policing team in Hounslow town centre, made up of over 20 officers, focused on the high street which has been a hotspot for crime. Businesses and shoppers say that it has made a positive difference.”

Image above: Minister of State for Crime, Policing and Fire, Chris Philp, MP for Croydon South

Government’s strategy for crime prevention

In response, Home Office Minister Chris Philp said he agreed people should be able to feel safe on their streets and antisocial behaviour should not be considered low level or minor crime. But he said the statistics showed that since 2010 violent crime had been reduced by 41% and criminal damage reduced by 68%. The statistics, from the Crime Survey, were endorsed by the Office of National Statistics.

London had more police officers that ever before, he said. “That is thanks to the police uplift programme that the Government funded.”

Why was it then, asked Andy Slaughter, that his constituents were telling him they had never felt less safe?

“Perception” said the Minister. It was important to change people’s perception of crime.

He blamed London’s Mayor Sadiq Khan for not doing more.

“London could have had another 1,000 officers on top of that, funded by the Government, but unfortunately Sadiq Khan was not able to organise himself to hire them, which is a great shame.

The Government had called on London’s Mayor Sadiq Khan to keep open 37 police stations planned for closure, but the only one he had changed his mind about “for reasons I can’t imagine” was Uxbridge.

Antisocial Behaviour Action Plan

He talked about the Government’s Antisocial Behaviour Action Plan, which involved “hot spot policing” and “immediate justice” – antisocial behaviour offenders having to do do community service wearing high-vis vests ideally within 48 hours of the offence – and the decision to ban Nitrous Oxide.

“We have an antisocial behaviour action plan, which was launched by the Prime Minister just a couple of months ago and is being rolled out as we speak. It has a number of elements … One is hotspot patrolling: antisocial behaviour hotspots are identified, and police officers are “surged” into those areas.

“Ten police force areas around the country are conducting pilots during the current financial year. I spoke to the police and crime commissioners about it today, and all the pilots will be up and running this month.

“From next April, every police force in the country—all 43 of the forces in England and Wales—will have hotspot policing, and there will be just over £1 million for each police force to fund the ASB patrols. That will be welcome, and will address some of the issues that the hon. Lady raised.

‘Immediate justice’ pilot

“There will also be 10 immediate justice pilots, again funded with about £1 million for each force, and starting this month.

“People who take part in antisocial behaviour will very quickly—ideally within 48 hours—have to undertake restorative work such as removing graffiti or cleaning up a park or a high street, wearing branded hi-vis jackets.

“Once the pilots have been completed this year, every police force in the country, from next April, will have an immediate justice project, again fully funded by the Government with £1 million for each police force—about £43 million in total.

“We are banning nitrous oxide, which I think will also help on the antisocial behaviour front. I hope Members will agree that the antisocial behaviour action plan, of which those measures are just a small part, will help us to clamp down on ASB in our communities. The total funding for the plan is about £160 million.”

Read more stories on The Chiswick Calendar