TfL’s plans could close down 600 year old Chiswick church says vicar

Image: Fr Simon Brandes, vicar of St Nicholas Church

“The plans TfL have come up with are so ridiculous, they are dangerous”

Plans put forward by Transport for London to make changes to Hogarth Roundabout could mean the closure of St Nicholas parish church, says vicar Fr Simon Brandes.

TfL wants to improve safety at the roundabout, particularly for motorcyclists where they turn off the roundabout onto the A316 outside the George and Devonshire pub, but their proposals include closing Church St, which gives access to Chiswick Mall.

St Nicholas Church on Church St is the oldest church in Chiswick, the centre of village life in the original riverside community, which dates bate to c.1181. The tower dates back to the early 1400s. Since Covid the church has been open seven days a week for people to come and use and, says Fr Brandes, the church community is flourishing.

Image: Diagram of the new proposals (click for larger versions); Image TfL

The church is in constant use

“People use the church for all sorts of things. It’s open from 9am to 4.30 / 5pm every day and there is always somebody in. The students from Latimer pre and Lower and Upper schools come here. It’s used by drama colleges, ArtsEd and others who hire the place to do music and make short films.

“We have concerts every third Sunday of the month, supporting young, emerging classical talent predominantly from the Royal School of Music. We also have our debt counselling service, which has grown significantly. That operates in the parish hall three days a week, Monday to Wednesday, and sometimes Friday as well, from 10am to 5pm. They have just taken on a new full-time worker to cope with the demand.

“People drive here, because it’s difficult to get here,” Fr Brandes told The Chiswick Calendar.

Image: Guests leaving a wedding at St Nicholas Church on Friday 19 July

The Chiswick Calendar reported last month that residents of Church Street and Chiswick Mall were against the proposal to close the road. They are regularly cut off by flooding from the River Thames at high tide, so Church Road is their only access road when the road beside the river is impassable, which the Old Chiswick Protection Society says happens 12 days a month, twice a day for 2-3 hours each time.

READ ALSO: Chiswick residents object to TfL plans for Hogarth Roundabout

Transport for London is proposing blocking off the end of Church Street at the roundabout, so anyone wanting to access Church St and the Mall would have to take the exit from the roundabout onto the A316, then turn immediately left and double back on themselves, making almost a 180 degree turn.

“The plans TfL have come up with are so ridiculous, they are dangerous” says Fr Brandes. “They are utterly impractical for anything larger than an old fashioned mini.”

Image: St Nicholas Church, Chiswick

“If we lose our congregation we will end up being an empty sepulchre”

The church is a popular choice during the summer months for weddings and is in frequent use for funerals.

“There is no way a hearse would make that turn.”

I asked whether saying the church could close because of Tfl’s plans was an exaggeration, especially as there are very few parking spaces available in Church St and Chiswick Mall for non-residents. Fr Brandes said it wasn’t.

“I think it is an existential threat. A lot of people do drive to us, parking is available after 5pm and at weekends. It’s difficult to get here without driving and people are creatures of habit. If the entries and exits are made so complicated, people won’t bother coming.

“We exist on voluntary contributions. We don’t receive money from the government or the diocese, we pay the diocese, and next year they are asking London churches for £99,950 to cover costs. All that money is paid for by voluntary contributions.

“If we lose our congregation, we will end up being an empty sepulchre.”

Image: The font at St Nicholas Church, Chiswick

TfL apologise for misleading figures

Transport for London are making changes to Hogarth Roundabout because of the number of accidents there have been. They have published a correction on their website saying they initially got those figures wrong. The correction says:

‘Since launching our consultation, we have identified an error in the following statement on our website. It stated:

‘Between January 2022 and June 2023 there were 25 slight and five serious motorcyclist collisions at Hogarth Roundabout.

‘This statement should have said:

‘Between July 2020 and June 2023 there were 18 slight and three serious casualties to the people involved in collisions at Hogarth Roundabout. Of the collisions recorded, six involved motorcyclists, one of which was serious.’

‘We would like to take this opportunity to apologise for this error.’

What is Hounslow Council’s view?

The planned changes have been put forward by TfL, but they involve LB Hounslow because the small road in in front of the George & Devonshire pub, which would become the alternate access route to Church St and Chiswick Mall belongs to them. We asked Hounslow Council for their view of the plans.

Councillor Katherine Dunne, Hounslow Council’s Cabinet Member for Climate, Environment & Transport, said:

 “The Council is aware of the consultation and would encourage residents to participate fully to make their views and concerns known directly to TfL.

“As part of this process, the Council has also been asked to officially respond to these proposals to make Hogarth Roundabout safer. Once we have reviewed the detailed plans we will be discussing any concerns with TfL in order to achieve the best outcome for the borough.”

Image: St Nicholas Church, Chiswick

TfL extends the consultation date

Transport for London has launched a public consultation, which opened on 11 July and is now due to finish on Thursday 12 September 2024, extended by a week.

Initially the closure date was to be Thursday 5 September, which also irritated residents. They asked for an extension.

“The summer holiday period is not a good time for a consultation. It’s not good practice to hold them when most people are away.”

Drop in sessions

There are two drop-in sessions planned for TfL to explain the changes at Hogarth’s House on 10 and 20 August.

“Drop-in sessions are no good to me” Maxine told us. “I need to sit down with them properly and explain to them how it will affect my business.”

If you would like to comment in the consultation, you can do so here: Have your say

Read more stories on The Chiswick Calendar